Showing posts with label spider man. Show all posts
Showing posts with label spider man. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 17, 2013

Marvel No Longer Pays Royalties to Inventor of a Spider-Man Toy

Newsflash from your Hollywood Attorney:




Marvel Enterprises will no longer have to pay royalties to Stephen Kimble, the inventor of a Spider-Man toy called the Web Blaster that allows users to mimic the character's web-shooting abilities with a foam string.

the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals begrudgingly gave Marvel a victory on the basis that the Supreme Court has restricted the kinds of contracts that can be made with patent owners.

Real money was at stake here. Since the product's invention in 1990, Kimble has earned $6 million in royalties from an agreement with Marvel that allowed him three percent of net product sales.

Read Full Ruling here.... http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2013/07/16/11-15605.pdf

In 1990, after Kimble patented his idea for a toy that was activated via a trigger attached to a valve in the palm of a glove, the inventor met with the president of one of Marvel's predecessor companies.
Marvel passed on the idea, and after the company began manufacturing a similar Spider-Man role-playing toy, Kimble sued in 1997 for patent infringement and a claim that the company had breached a contract to pay him for use of his idea. The patent claim was dismissed, but a judge ruled there were genuine issues of fact precluding summary judgment on the contract claim, entering a judgment that awarded him 3.5 percent of sales. Both sides appealed.
In 2001, the parties came to a settlement agreement. As part of the deal, Marvel purchased the patent for more than $516,000 and also agreed to give him 3 percent of net product sales. (Kimble later sold an interest in his property to Robert Grabb, a co-appellant.)

Kimble then filed a new lawsuit for breach of contract, and Marvel submitted counterclaims that sought a declaration that it was no longer obligated to pay Kimble based on the sale of products after the expiration of his patent.

That has the Ninth Circuit reviewing Brulotte v. Thys Co., a 1964 Supreme Court decision which forbids patent holders from collecting royalties after the expiration date of the patent. Where it gets tricky is so-called "hybrid agreements" that allow for payments during the patent period and non-patent period. In baseball, this would be equivalent to the Los Angeles Dodgers agreeing to lock up a young superstar beyond his early restricted free agent years.
Courts around the nation have been dubious about royalty payments under hybrid agreements, not wishing to allow patent holders to use their leverage in the early years of a patent's issuance. The Ninth Circuit has been more careful on this topic, reviewing a later 1979 Supreme Court case and holding that there should at least be a discount in the post-expiration period.

On appeal, Kimble argued that the settlement agreement with Marvel distinguishes between patent and non-patent rights and that Brulotte did not apply.
Ninth Circuit Judge Consuelo Callahan writes, "We cannot agree because the agreement plainly involved one royalty rate for both patent and Web Blaster rights, with no discount or other clear indication that the Web Blaster royalties were not subject to patent leverage."

Read More.... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/appeals-court-frees-marvel-spider-586148


http://lawofficesofjonathanfranklin.blogspot.com/

Law Offices of Jonathan Franklin
Open Evenings and Weekends this Summer
Call Us Now (310) 273-9600   
 http://www.jonathanfranklinlaw.com


Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Julie Taymor's Lawsuit Over 'Spider-Man' Musical Set for May Trial


Sometimes, a "settlement" doesn't mean a settlement.

Julie Taymor's Spider-Man: Turn off the Dark was supposed to be an epic -- the most expensive Broadway musical ever with audacious stunts and music from U2's Bono and The Edge.

The production now continues without her involvement, but the lawsuit survives and has become a thing to behold in its own right.

Taymor alleges that her contributions continue to be used in the musical and that she deserves compensation for this. The lawsuit was "settled" in August, but the parties had trouble reaching a final agreement. Then Taymor's attorney told the judge everyone was "within days" of a final settlement. And yet, the parties have yet been able to come to a final final agreement.

The judge reportedly is frustrated. On Friday, U.S. District Court Judge Katherine Forrest decided enough is enough and, after pointing to sealed correspondence between the parties.

Read More... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/julie-taymors-lawsuit-spider-man-429453


Thursday, January 24, 2013

‘Spider-Man’ Producers, Taymor Reach Settlement, Lawyer Says


The producers of the Broadway musical “Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark” settled a lawsuit brought by the show’s fired director, Julie Taymor, two weeks after a judge set a May trial date, a lawyer for Taymor said.

U.S. District Judge Katherine Forrest in New York, who is presiding over the case, on Jan. 10 restored the case to her active court calendar, saying that while both sides told her in August they had agreed to a tentative settlement over royalties and creative control, they hadn’t completed it. Forrest also scheduled a May 27 trial date.

“The parties have now reached an agreement on terms to settle the above litigation and have a fully drafted settlement agreement that the parties are ready to execute,” Charles Spada, a lawyer for Taymor, wrote to Forrest in a Jan. 22 letter made public yesterday. “We anticipate notifying the court within the next week that a final settlement agreement has been executed and that the litigation can be dismissed.”

Taymor was removed from the $75 million show in March 2011, after critics lambasted it during an extended 182-performance preview period. She sued the producers in November 2011, saying they violated her intellectual-property rights by making changes without her permission and didn’t pay royalties due her as a co-book writer.

In 2003, producers began negotiating with Marvel Entertainment, a unit of The Walt Disney Co. (DIS) that owns the rights to the character, about staging “Spider-Man” on Broadway, according to Taymor’s suit.

The original producing team asked Bono and The Edge of the band U2 to write a score and Taymor to direct. In 2004, she wrote a three-page treatment for the show and the following year she registered it with the U.S. Copyright Office, according to her suit.

In her complaint, Taymor said that as the musical’s co- author she was owed guaranteed minimum royalties of $2,917.50 a week. The producers agreed in February to pay her director’s royalties as part of a settlement with the Stage Directors and Choreographers Society.

In his letter to the court, Spada said the settlement had been conditional upon 8 Legged Productions and non-party Marvel Entertainment entering into a separate agreement to amend 8 Legged’s license to produce the Spider-Man musical.

“It now appears that 8-Legged and Marvel will be executing a formal amendment to their licensing agreement within days,” he wrote.

The case is Taymor v. 8 Legged Productions LLC, 11-cv- 08002, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York (Manhattan).