Showing posts with label Marvel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Marvel. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Disney Wins Over Stan Lee Media in Marvel Copyright Lawsuit

Newsflash from your Hollywood Attorney:



Turns out the Walt Disney Company really does own the rights to the Marvel characters created by Stan Lee, at least according to a federal judge today. U.S. District Judge William J. Martinez Thursday granted with prejudice Disney’s motion to dismiss Stan Lee Media’s multibillion-dollar lawsuit superhero copyright suit. In his 11-page order (read it here) Martinez did little to hide his annoyance with the litigious SLMI. “Plaintiff has tried time and again to claim ownership of those copyrights; the litigation history arising out of the 1998 Agreement stretches over more than a decade and at least six courts,” he wrote of the company’s many legal moves.

This latest attempt started in mid-October 2012 when SLMI filed a copyright infringement complaint seeking the profits from the $5.5 billion it said that Disney made from Marvel superhero movies and merchandise based on characters created by Lee. In its suit, SLMI claimed that Lee, who no longer has anything to do with the company with his name, signed over the rights to comic book characters like Iron Man, the Hulk, the Fantastic Four, the X-Men, Spider-Man and many more that he created or would create to its corporate predecessor in October 1998 for shares in the company. In November 1998, Lee signed an agreement with Marvel handing over the rights to the same characters. In late November 2012, Disney, who purchased Marvel for $4 billion in 2009, filed its motion to dismiss, calling the lawsuit is “completely frivolous.” The November 30 motion to dismiss, like the initial suit by SLMI, was filed in Colorado.

Judge Martinez obviously agreed with Disney and he wants to make sure that SLMI think twice before trying to use the courts in such a manner again. “Taking its cue from the Southern District of New York and the Central District of California, this Court holds that Plaintiff is precluded from re-litigating the issue of its ownership of copyrights based on the 1998 Agreement, which issue was decided against it,” he wrote today. Disney was represented by James Quinn, R. Bruce Rich and Randi W. Singer of New York’s Weil Gotshal & Manges and Frederick J. Baumann and Holly Ludwig of Denver firm Rothgerber Johnson & Lyons. Stan Lee Media was represented by John McDermott of the Denver office of Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck and Robert Chapman and Jon Jamison Hill out of the LA’s Eisner Kahan Gorry Chapman Ross & Jaffe.

Source..... http://www.deadline.com

Stay Safe Out There - If You Need Help just Give Me a Call!

To schedule a free consultation and learn how we can help you, contact Beverly Hills DUI Attorney Jonathan Franklin today.


http://lawofficesofjonathanfranklin.blogspot.com/

Law Offices of Jonathan Franklin
Open Evenings and Weekends this Summer
Call Us Now (310) 273-9600   
 http://www.jonathanfranklinlaw.com


Wednesday, July 17, 2013

Marvel No Longer Pays Royalties to Inventor of a Spider-Man Toy

Newsflash from your Hollywood Attorney:




Marvel Enterprises will no longer have to pay royalties to Stephen Kimble, the inventor of a Spider-Man toy called the Web Blaster that allows users to mimic the character's web-shooting abilities with a foam string.

the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals begrudgingly gave Marvel a victory on the basis that the Supreme Court has restricted the kinds of contracts that can be made with patent owners.

Real money was at stake here. Since the product's invention in 1990, Kimble has earned $6 million in royalties from an agreement with Marvel that allowed him three percent of net product sales.

Read Full Ruling here.... http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2013/07/16/11-15605.pdf

In 1990, after Kimble patented his idea for a toy that was activated via a trigger attached to a valve in the palm of a glove, the inventor met with the president of one of Marvel's predecessor companies.
Marvel passed on the idea, and after the company began manufacturing a similar Spider-Man role-playing toy, Kimble sued in 1997 for patent infringement and a claim that the company had breached a contract to pay him for use of his idea. The patent claim was dismissed, but a judge ruled there were genuine issues of fact precluding summary judgment on the contract claim, entering a judgment that awarded him 3.5 percent of sales. Both sides appealed.
In 2001, the parties came to a settlement agreement. As part of the deal, Marvel purchased the patent for more than $516,000 and also agreed to give him 3 percent of net product sales. (Kimble later sold an interest in his property to Robert Grabb, a co-appellant.)

Kimble then filed a new lawsuit for breach of contract, and Marvel submitted counterclaims that sought a declaration that it was no longer obligated to pay Kimble based on the sale of products after the expiration of his patent.

That has the Ninth Circuit reviewing Brulotte v. Thys Co., a 1964 Supreme Court decision which forbids patent holders from collecting royalties after the expiration date of the patent. Where it gets tricky is so-called "hybrid agreements" that allow for payments during the patent period and non-patent period. In baseball, this would be equivalent to the Los Angeles Dodgers agreeing to lock up a young superstar beyond his early restricted free agent years.
Courts around the nation have been dubious about royalty payments under hybrid agreements, not wishing to allow patent holders to use their leverage in the early years of a patent's issuance. The Ninth Circuit has been more careful on this topic, reviewing a later 1979 Supreme Court case and holding that there should at least be a discount in the post-expiration period.

On appeal, Kimble argued that the settlement agreement with Marvel distinguishes between patent and non-patent rights and that Brulotte did not apply.
Ninth Circuit Judge Consuelo Callahan writes, "We cannot agree because the agreement plainly involved one royalty rate for both patent and Web Blaster rights, with no discount or other clear indication that the Web Blaster royalties were not subject to patent leverage."

Read More.... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/appeals-court-frees-marvel-spider-586148


http://lawofficesofjonathanfranklin.blogspot.com/

Law Offices of Jonathan Franklin
Open Evenings and Weekends this Summer
Call Us Now (310) 273-9600   
 http://www.jonathanfranklinlaw.com


Friday, July 5, 2013

Disney Distribution Deals for 10 Specific Characters says to Viacom, "We want Our Characters Back"


When Walt Disney (NYSE: DIS) bought Marvel for $4 billion in cash and stock, the House of Mouse didn't secure all the benefits of owning the superhero portfolio.

Sony (NYSE: SNE) still owned the rights to produce and distribute the Spider-Man and Ghost Rider franchises. Twenty-First Century Fox's (NASDAQ: FOX) forerunner, News Corp., held the rights to the X-Men, the Fantastic Four, and Daredevil. And Marvel did come with the production rights to the rest of its own portfolio, but with distribution deals for 10 specific characters via Viacom's (NASDAQ: VIAB) Paramount Pictures.

That's a side effect of Marvel's complicated financing deal from 2005, which set the stage for the studio to take control of its own destiny. But as I said, Marvel also signed away some important rights in the process, and allowed Sony, Fox, and Paramount to grab a slice of Marvel's financial success.

Disney is busy getting its superheroes back. The company just bought back the distribution rights for back-catalog titles Iron Man, Iron Man 2, Thor, and Captain America: The First Avenger from Paramount. Financial terms are unknown, but the payout is probably smaller than the last superhero buyback.

In 2010, Disney acquired the rights to release The Avengers and Iron Man 3. Fellow Fool Tim Beyers worked his calculator to the melting point to figure out that Paramount would get something like $90 million out of the Avengers arrangement, and something on that level for Iron Man 3 as well. Given that the new repurchase deals with older titles, the total cost in unlikely to crack the $100 million mark.

So it's a drop in the bucket next to Viacom's filmed entertainment revenues, which topped $4.8 billion last year. The rounding error is even smaller next to Disney's $5.8 billion in studio sales. The big takeaway here is that Disney is very interested in taking full control of its superhero assets. I would not be surprised to see the Mouse reaching out to Sony and Fox to regain the last of its prodigal superhuman sons and daughters.

Read More.... http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2013/07/03/disney-wants-its-heroes-back-from-viacom.aspx

Law Offices of Jonathan Franklin
Open Evenings and Weekends this Summer
Call Us Now (310) 273-9600   
 http://www.jonathanfranklinlaw.com


Thursday, June 20, 2013

Marvel's Ghost Rider Reinstated - Lawsuit


 A lawsuit against comic book publisher Marvel Entertainment by a man who claims he owns the rights to the Ghost Rider character was reinstated on Tuesday, June 11, 2013. The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a 2011 lower-court decision that dismissed the lawsuit brought by Gary Friedrich, who had sued in 2007, claiming he was owed a cut of the box office proceeds from a film version starring Nicolas Cage.

A lawsuit against comic book publisher Marvel Entertainment by a man who claims he owns the rights to the Ghost Rider character was reinstated on Tuesday.

The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed a 2011 lower-court decision that dismissed the lawsuit brought by Gary Friedrich, who had sued in 2007, claiming he was owed a cut of the box office proceeds from a film version starring Nicolas Cage.

The comic features a motorcycle-riding character with a flaming skull named Johnny Blaze, who agreed to let the devil have his soul in return for his adoptive father being cured of cancer. The cover of its 1972 debut says it was conceived and written by Friedrich.

The lower court found that Friedrich relinquished his rights in a 1979 agreement with Marvel. But the appeals court on Tuesday found that the contract language was open to dispute.

"There are genuine disputes of material fact regarding the parties' intent to assign renewal rights in that agreement, the timeliness of Friedrich's ownership claim, and the authorship of the work," the court said in sending the case back for trial.

An email sent Tuesday to a representative for Marvel Entertainment LLC seeking comment did not immediately get a response.

Read More...  http://www.bellinghamherald.com/2013/06/11/3047833/ny-ghost-rider-lawsuit-reinstated.html#storylink=cpy

Law Offices of Jonathan Franklin
Open Evenings and Weekends this Summer
Call Us Now (310) 273-9600    
 http://www.jonathanfranklinlaw.com



Tuesday, June 11, 2013

Legal Victory Overturned Against "Ghost Rider" by "Marvel"


The 2nd Circuit remands for trial the issue of who holds rights to the popular comic book character.

Comic book author Gary Friedrich has kept alive his long-running case against Marvel over rights to Ghost Rider.

Friedrich introduced Ghost Rider's origin story in 1972′s Marvel Spotlight #5, and mostly disappeared from the comic world in the late 1970s due to reported bouts of alcoholism. But a decade ago, he heard about a planned movie version of Ghost Rider -- a motorcycle-riding superhero with supernatural powers and a flaming skull for a head -- and asserted that he still controlled rights to what has been over the years one of Marvel's most successful comic book franchises.

In late 2011, after a movie starring Nicolas Cage had come out, a federal judge ruled that Friedrich had handed over rights to Marvel in contracts as a freelancer working for the studio in the 1970s.

On Tuesday, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals vacated that ruling, saying that the judge had erred in granting summary judgment and that the contracts that Friedrich signed were "ambiguous" and needed further investigation at trial. Here's the full ruling.

Like many contributors to Marvel's stable, Friedrich worked under the so-called "Marvel Method" of creation, and in this dispute, Marvel asserted that the Ghost Rider characters and story were created through a collaborative process with Marvel personnel and resources.

At primary issue in this case is who controls the renewal term of the Ghost Rider copyright. Copyright law confers multiple terms -- an initial term of 28 years and a renewal term of 67 years. When Congress enacted changes to copyright law in the mid-'70s, the purpose of the renewal term was to "provide authors a second opportunity to obtain remuneration for their works" and "to renegotiate the terms of the grant once the value of the work has been tested."

After learning that copyright law allowed a renewal of the term to vest with the original author, Friedrich filed for, and received, a renewal and copyright registration for his work in Spotlight #5, and then sued Marvel and their licensees for copyright infringement and other claims.

At the District Court level, a judge ruled that Friedrich's 1978 agreement with Marvel where he agreed to grant "to Marvel forever all rights of any kind and nature in and to the Work" precluded Friedrich's claims over ownership, as he had given up the renewal term.

But 2nd Circuit appellate judge Denny Chin says not so fast, saying that the 1978 contract "is ambiguous on its face," pointing to a sentence that defined the work as "ungrammatical and awkwardly phrased" and unclear "whether it covered a work published six years earlier" and "whether it conveys renewal rights."

"The contract contains no explicit reference to renewal rights and most of the language merely tracks the 1976 Act's definition of 'work made for hire,'" writes Judge Chin. "The Agreement could reasonably be construed as a form work-for-hire contract having nothing to do with renewal rights."

As the judge notes, there is a strong presumption against the conveyance of renewal rights, and in this decision, Judge Chin goes out of his way to give Friedrich the benefit of the doubt. At the time of the 1978 deal, the appeals judge says:

                           "Spotlight 5 had been published six years earlier by a different corporate entity (Magazine Mgmt.) and had grown so popular that Marvel had already reprinted it once and had launched a separate Ghost Rider comic book series. Given that context, it is doubtful the parties intended to convey rights in the valuable Ghost Rider copyright without explicitly referencing it. It is more likely that the Agreement only covered ongoing or future work. Hence, there is a genuine dispute regarding the parties' intent for this form contract to cover Ghost Rider."

The judge adds that when Friedrich made his deal with Marvel in 1978, he could have entered into an "employee for hire" relationship, but not necessarily one that rendered Ghost Rider as a "work made for hire" ex post facto.

Marvel also argued that Friedrich's claims were barred by the statute of limitations because it had repudiated his ownership claims long before the comic book writer had brought his lawsuit. Marvel also pointed to widely circulated news reports about a movie that allegedly implicitly repudiated Friedrich's ownership claims. The Second Circuit says it is too soon to give Marvel these points, but the statute of limitations does appear to be an issue that will be addressed now that the dispute has been remanded back down to the trial court for more consideration.

In today's ruling, the appeals court also has to consider whether the trial judge erred by denying Friedrich's own motion for summary judgment that he is the unquestionable author of Ghost Rider.

Hinting at where this case is going next, Judge Chin writes, "When construed in Marvel's favor, the record reveals that Friedrich had nothing more than an uncopyrightable idea for a motorcycle-riding character when he presented it to Marvel because he had not yet fixed the idea into a tangible medium."

The judge adds that a jury could reasonably conclude that artists and others at Marvel at the time developed Ghost Rider through collaborative efforts, which would indeed make it a "work made for hire" and Marvel, the sole statutory author.

But that will be decided at trial, assuming there's no settlement or some unexpected twist.

Read More.... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/marvels-ghost-rider-legal-victory-566170


Thursday, April 25, 2013

End of Dispute Over "Iron Man 3" Ticket Terms between Disney & Theatre Owners


Last week, AMC and Regal Entertainment, the two other largest U.S. circuits,yanked advance sales for the tentpole because of the impasse. And earlier this week, Regal went so far as to pull all marketing materials for the threequel, including trailers.

Neither AMC nor Disney immediately comment. A deal with Regal is expected as well.

Studio insiders say it has been seven years since Disney revisited its terms, and that in that time, it has upped its profile by acquiring Pixar, Marvel and now LucasFilm.

There was plenty of incentive for all sides to resolve their differences. Based on tracking, Iron Man 3 (starring Robert Downey Jr.) could open between $135 million and $145 million in North America, ahead of the $128.1 million debut of Iron Man 2 three years ago. Gwyneth Paltrow and Don Cheadle also are returning cast members.

Directed by franchise newcomer Shane Black, Iron Man 3 is already rolling out overseas, where it opened to a stellar $13.2 million in a dozen markets on Wednesday. By Sunday, the tentpole will have opened in 80 percent of the international market and is expected to collect north of $110 million.

http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/iron-man-3-disney-theater-446536












Friday, March 8, 2013

Stan Lee to Be Deposed in Billion-Dollar Lawsuit Against Disney


The 90-year-old comic book legend, who's reportedly experiencing health issues, will address his working relationship with Marvel over the years.

Stan Lee, the comic book genius who co-created such legendary characters as Spider-Man, Iron Man and X-Men, will be deposed next week in a billion-dollar lawsuit against Disney.

He will be questioned by lawyers representing Stan Lee Media, the company bearing his name that he abandoned a decade ago. The lawsuit aims to prove that Disney has committed copyright infringement on valuable characters since 2009 that allegedly were raided when SLM filed for bankruptcy.

Discovery in the case was put on hold this week because a Colorado federal judge said that the lawsuit potentially could be ended upon pending Disney motions, but the judge has carved out room for the plaintiffs to potentially question Lee about whether he ever owned copyrights to his valuable characters or whether his work was done as a "work for hire." The deposition is happening upon word given to the judge that the 90-year-old Lee is experiencing health problems.

SLM has brought many challenges over what happened after 2001, when it filed for Chapter 11 three years after the company was founded.

Judges in New York and California have been less than tolerant in allowing claims to be heard. SLM's shareholders first had their standing challenged, and after getting their postbankruptcy house in order, whether their claims had already been adjudicated. In July, for instance, a lawsuit was dismissed that alleged that Lee colluded to divert SLM's assets to his other companies, QED Prods and Pow! Entertainment, before he made peace with Marvel.

In October, SLM came up with a new legal strategy to sue Disney, which acquired Marvel in 2009.

Lawyers for SLM insist that their claims are novel and will not fall short on res judicata grounds, meaning the matter had already been judged. For example, they believe they can prove that Disney infringed rights to create last year's blockbuster film The Avengers.

Disney has a host of arguments as to why it believes that SLM will fall short once again.

Before even getting to the merits of the claims, Disney is challenging the Colorado court's jurisdiction to hear the matter. The Walt Disney Co. is a "holding company and as such does not conduct business in Colorado or anywhere else," it says.

A federal judge will soon will rule on Disney's jurisdictional challenge and also might address res judicata, the statute of limitations, and various other defenses.

"It is not clear whether the pending Motion to Dismiss will dispose of the entire action," U.S. Magistrate Judge Kathleen Tafoya wrote. "However, personal jurisdiction is necessary for the Court to entertain claims against a party. … It is clear that should the pending motion be granted, this Court will have expended resources managing a complex suit unnecessarily in the absence of a stay."

Thus, Tafoya granted Disney's motion to stay discovery, but only in part.

What won't be delayed is the deposition of Lee.

SLM has reported that there are "health concerns" for Lee, who the company calls a "central witness." The plaintiff cites his age and a news release where Lee acknowledged having a pacemaker implanted in September.

Although SLM still stands long odds in making its billion-dollar case, the company's followers might gain some satisfaction in questioning Lee about the SLM chapter of his storied life.

The questions likely will explore his long and sometimes turbulent relationship with Marvel and the collaborative process that's been dubbed the "Marvel Method."

Under U.S. Copyright law, when artists and writers work for studios under "work for hire" agreements, the studio is deemed to be the "author" with control over the copyright.

In a filing in January, Disney indicated that it doesn't believe that SLM ever had rights to Iron Man, X-Men, The Avengers and Spider-Man.

"If this case proceeds on the merits, [Disney] will establish that the 1998 Agreement did not convey the supposed rights Plaintiff assert -- most prominently because, even if the 1998 Agreement could be construed as implicating the rights to any Marvel character (and it did not), all of them were owned by Marvel, not Lee, as works made for hire under the governing provisions of copyright law."

The plaintiffs indicate that will be the topic of discussion at a deposition March 13. Lee will give his opinion and likely be pushed to explain why he started SLM in the first place.

Source... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/stan-lee-disney-comic-book-426908

Thursday, January 31, 2013

Marvel Entertainment, Broadway Spider-Man, and Marvel Briefcase Suits


The on-again, off-again litigation between director Julie Taymor and producers of the Broadway musical, Spider-Man: Turn off the Dark, appears to be going dark again. Earlier in the month, the litigation was revived when the parties admitted there was still some work on the settlement negotiating front. Last week, Taymor's attorney Charles Spada notified the court that a final settlement agreement would be executed soon, describing the hold-up as being for producer 8 Legged Production and non-party Marvel Entertainment to to amend a license to produce the Spider-Man musical. Spada said that "8 Legged and Marvel will be executing a formal amendment to their licensing agreement within days."


Speaking of Marvel, the studio has gotten out of an odd dispute over a briefcase featured in The Avengers. Last August, Rimowa GmbH, a German manufacturer of luxury travel briefcases, sued because the Topas attaché case seen being used by Samuel L. Jackson's character Nick Fury was allegedly repurposed as the packaging for Blu-ray versions of the film. Last week, the parties stipulated to dismiss the case with prejudice. No further terms of the agreement were made public.


Read More... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/hollywood-docket-hobbit-slot-machine-417117

Thursday, January 24, 2013

‘Spider-Man’ Producers, Taymor Reach Settlement, Lawyer Says


The producers of the Broadway musical “Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark” settled a lawsuit brought by the show’s fired director, Julie Taymor, two weeks after a judge set a May trial date, a lawyer for Taymor said.

U.S. District Judge Katherine Forrest in New York, who is presiding over the case, on Jan. 10 restored the case to her active court calendar, saying that while both sides told her in August they had agreed to a tentative settlement over royalties and creative control, they hadn’t completed it. Forrest also scheduled a May 27 trial date.

“The parties have now reached an agreement on terms to settle the above litigation and have a fully drafted settlement agreement that the parties are ready to execute,” Charles Spada, a lawyer for Taymor, wrote to Forrest in a Jan. 22 letter made public yesterday. “We anticipate notifying the court within the next week that a final settlement agreement has been executed and that the litigation can be dismissed.”

Taymor was removed from the $75 million show in March 2011, after critics lambasted it during an extended 182-performance preview period. She sued the producers in November 2011, saying they violated her intellectual-property rights by making changes without her permission and didn’t pay royalties due her as a co-book writer.

In 2003, producers began negotiating with Marvel Entertainment, a unit of The Walt Disney Co. (DIS) that owns the rights to the character, about staging “Spider-Man” on Broadway, according to Taymor’s suit.

The original producing team asked Bono and The Edge of the band U2 to write a score and Taymor to direct. In 2004, she wrote a three-page treatment for the show and the following year she registered it with the U.S. Copyright Office, according to her suit.

In her complaint, Taymor said that as the musical’s co- author she was owed guaranteed minimum royalties of $2,917.50 a week. The producers agreed in February to pay her director’s royalties as part of a settlement with the Stage Directors and Choreographers Society.

In his letter to the court, Spada said the settlement had been conditional upon 8 Legged Productions and non-party Marvel Entertainment entering into a separate agreement to amend 8 Legged’s license to produce the Spider-Man musical.

“It now appears that 8-Legged and Marvel will be executing a formal amendment to their licensing agreement within days,” he wrote.

The case is Taymor v. 8 Legged Productions LLC, 11-cv- 08002, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York (Manhattan).