Showing posts with label ESPN. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ESPN. Show all posts

Thursday, March 27, 2014

Surprising Entertainment #Lawsuits for the Week

Newsflash from your Hollywood Attorney:








Summit Entertainment has scored a round in an ongoing trademark dispute with Bath & Body Works over a line of "Twilight" fragrances.

The lawsuit has been ongoing for three years now, and BBW sought declaratory relief to establish its rights to use "Twilight Woods" and "Twilight Crush" and that it would not infringe or tarnish the marks of the producer of the blockbuster 2008 film.
On March 21, U.S. District Judge George Daniels denied a motion for summary judgment filed by BBW.
In his opinion, the New York federal judge writes that Summit has presented significant evidence that its marks are strong, and that viewing the evidence in Summit's favor, a reasonable jury could conclude similarity in trade dress and consumer confusion as to the source of the cosmetics. The judge also says that a jury could conclude that BBW intended to associate itself with Twilight.
Notwithstanding a potential settlement, the case appears headed to trial.  Read Opinion here.... http://www.scribd.com/doc/214118527/Twilight-Trademark-Opinion

Earlier this month, photographer Brian Masck kept his lawsuit alive against Sports Illustrated for allegedly infringing his iconic 1991 photo of former University of Michigan football superstar Desmond Howard doing a "Heisman" pose during a game. Now comes the follow-up lawsuit. On Monday, he filed a new copyright infringement lawsuit against ESPN. The complaint, long on backstory, says "ESPN The Magazine did everything SI did, but the photo appeared only once, in the last print appearance of the photograph, in the issue dated October 3, 2012."  Ruling..... http://www.scribd.com/doc/214661773/Heisman

50 Cent has gotten a partial victory in a lawsuit brought against a DJ who ran hip-hop website WorldStarHipHop.com. The main controversy in the lawsuit had to do with the website's masthead featuring an image of the rapper. In a ruling on Monday, a federal judge granted the hip-hop star summary judgment on copyright and right of publicity claims. In doing so, the judge rejected affirmative defenses including fair use. According to the ruling, "Defendants provide no authority to support the fair use of a celebrity’s image or likeness. This is not surprising, as a celebrity’s image, standing alone, only evokes that celebrity’s persona. Jackson’s image does not, by itself, describe anything about Defendants’ website." Read Heree.....  http://www.scribd.com/doc/214626446/50-Cent-v-World-Star-Hip-Hop-Opinion

Much has been made of an Illinois federal judge's decision at the end of last year that pretty much put most of what we know about the Sherlock Holmes character in the public domain. The case is now on appeal, and the estate of Arthur Conan Doyle figures to make some interesting arguments. Meanwhile, the estate has signaled that it intends to protect its trademarks going forward. Case in point: Last week, the estate opposed an attempt by Rocket Pictures to register "Sherlock Gnomes." Rocket intends Sherlock Gnomes to be the follow-up to its 2011 computer animated feature Gnomeo & Juliet. The Conan Doyle estate says it will dilute their own hold on Sherlock Holmes. Here's the papers filed with the Trademark Office.....   http://www.scribd.com/doc/214666850/Sherlock-Gnomes

Finally today comes a ruling from a Texas judge. In the lawsuit, the plaintiff claimed that the 1989 film Tango & Cash, starring Sylvester Stallone and Kurt Russell, defamed him because Russell's character appeared in the movie "dressed as a woman with lipstick, a woman's miniskirt, and woman's high heel shoes." The plaintiff says his teenage friends teased him because he shares the same first name ("Gabriel") as Russell's character. Of course, the claim goes nowhere. The judge fails to find any statement "of and concerning the plaintiff," and the claim was also barred by the statute of limitations.   Read Here..... http://www.scribd.com/doc/214668019/Tango-Cash


Stay Safe Out There - If You Need Help just Give Me a Call!

To schedule a free consultation and learn how we can help you, contact Beverly Hills DUI Attorney Jonathan Franklin today.

http://lawofficesofjonathanfranklin.blogspot.com/


Law Offices of Jonathan Franklin
Open Evenings and Weekends this Summer
Call Us Now (310) 273-9600   
 http://www.jonathanfranklinlaw.com


Thursday, February 28, 2013

ESPN Ordered to Pay Dish Network $4.86 Million for Breach of Contract


A jury verdict came after three weeks of trial and one day of jury deliberation in a case over a 2005 licensing agreement.

After a day of deliberation, a federal jury gave a mixed verdict in Dish Network's lawsuit against ESPN for allegedly breaching the terms of a 2005 licensing agreement. Dish has been awarded $4.86 million after prevailing on one of its four breach-of-contract claims.

Dish spent nearly three weeks in a New York federal court attempting to prove that ESPN had violated a "most favored nation" clause in an eight-year licensing agreement. The contractual provision entitled Dish to be given the opportunity of receiving equal treatment on subscriber rates and packaging conditions when ESPN gave Dish's competitors better deals.

Specifically, Dish accused ESPN of allowing Comcast to remove packaging requirements that allowed ESPN Classic to be distributed beyond its most widely-distributed tier; of allowing DirecTV, Verizon and Time Warner Cable to have lower subscription rates on ESPN Deportes; and allowing others a la carte rights on ESPNHD, ESPN Classic, ESPNU and ESPN2.

Additionally, Dish brought a fourth breach of contract claim against ESPN for granting Time Warner Cable the ability to distribute its networks on the Internet without imposing a subscription fee.

Dish had alleged that the damages added up to more than $150 million, but the jury said that a lot less was due in order to make the satellite distributor whole. Dish only won on the claim over ESPN Deportes. Under its original agreement, Dish was obligated to pay a monthly subscriber fee of 35-47 cents for ESPN Deportes between 2007 and 2013, but then TWC got a deal for 8-18 cents and Verizon got a deal for 3 cents.

At trial, Dish presented ESPN as being careless when it came to looking after its contractual obligations and not promptly making "MFN" offers when they were due. Dish also showcased internal ESPN e-mails that calculated how licensing negotiations with other MVPDs impacted the money that was owed to Dish and how to "finesse" the obligations for financial advantage.

On the witness stand, ESPN's executives denied that Dish was robbed of the benefit of making its 2005 agreement and made the case that calculating "MNF" offers was complicated and took time. The ESPN execs said that offers were eventually made to Dish and that the company was credited with the benefit retroactively.

Dish's current carriage deal with ESPN expires in September.

Dish was represented by lead lawyer Barry Ostrager. ESPN was represented by Diane Sullivan.

ESPN said in a statement, "We are gratified that the jury rejected all but one of Dish’s claims and all but $4.8 million of the more than $153 million in damages they were seeking.“

Read More... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/espn-ordered-pay-dish-network-425347

Monday, February 11, 2013

Dish sues ESPN for $150M over alleged licensing terms


ESPN Accused in Dish Case of Giving Comcast Better Terms
Dish Network Corp. is headed to court seeking $150 million from Walt Disney Co.’s ESPN for allegedly breaching a contract by offering competitors including Comcast Corp. better licensing terms for sports programming.

Dish, the third largest pay-TV provider, sued ESPN in 2009 for violating a so-called most-favored-nation clause in their distribution agreement, which it said requires the sports network to offer Dish the same terms it offers a competitor. A jury trial is set to begin today in Manhattan federal court.

ESPN argued in a court filing that it eventually granted Dish the terms offered to competitors. U.S. District Judge John Koeltl denied a motion for judgment without a trial in April 2011, saying it was up to a jury to decide whether the terms were similar.

“All contracts are confidential and for most-favored- nation, it’s difficult to maintain compliance,” Aditi Bagchi, a professor of contract law at Fordham University Law School in New York, said in a phone interview. “Suing is a way to extract information. Dish can claim the contract’s been violated and force some information out of ESPN.”

TV distributors pay ESPN and other cable programmers fees based on ratings and the number of subscribers. According to the media research firm SNL Kagan, ESPN charges TV providers about $5.13 a month per subscriber on average, one of the highest rates in the industry.

DirecTV Deal
In court papers, Englewood, Colorado-based Dish listed various deals it said were offered only to competitors. Dish said ESPN allowed DirecTV, the second largest pay-TV provider and a rival in the satellite-TV business, to move the sports documentary network ESPN Classic to a less-populated tier of subscribers, which would result in lower payments. ESPN also let DirecTV pay a lower rate per subscriber for the Spanish-language network ESPN Deportes, Dish said.

Dish claimed that ESPN offered Comcast, the largest pay-TV company, the right to distribute the college sports network ESPNU to bars and taverns on better terms than it got.

Distribution Agreement
Dish and ESPN signed an eight-year distribution agreement in 2005. Dish said in its complaint that it learned from press releases and news reports in 2009 that ESPN had made deals with Comcast and DirecTV that “contain more favorable provisions than ESPN has given to Dish.” In June 2009, Dish sent a letter to ESPN demanding the same terms and claimed that ESPN failed to offer them.

Since the lawsuit was filed, Dish has said that ESPN also made more favorable agreements with the TV distributors Time Warner Cable Inc., Verizon Communications Inc. and AT&T Inc. None of Dish’s competitors are named as defendants in the suit.

ESPN is 80 percent owned by Burbank, California-based Disney and 20 percent by New York-based Hearst Corp.

The case is Dish Network LLC v. ESPN Inc., 09-06875, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York (Manhattan).

Read More... http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-02-11/espn-accused-in-dish-case-of-giving-comcast-better-terms.html

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

Judge: NCAA Athletes in Lawsuit Can Go After Live TV Cash


The NCAA lost a court battle this week when a federal judge shot down a motion that would have prohibited college athletes involved in a lawsuit from receiving a portion of the billions of dollars generated by live television rights.

The ruling comes as college athletes find themselves cut out of an increasingly-lucrative industry where major networks like Disney’s (DIS) ESPN pay top dollar to televise hugely popular college football and basketball games.

Last year a long-running antitrust lawsuit led by former college basketball star Ed O’Bannon amended its suit to claim a piece of all TV game revenue, instead of just money generated by rebroadcasts.

While the NCAA objected to the amendment on procedural grounds, on Tuesday federal Judge Claudia Wilken rejected the NCAA’s motion to preclude the lawsuit from advancing. 

“Now the (NCAA and its co-defendants) are facing potential liability that's based on the billions of dollars in revenue instead of tens or hundreds of millions," Michael Hausfeld, interim lead counsel for the plaintiffs, told ESPN. "It's a more accurate context for what the players deserve."

“Although our motion to strike was denied, the judge has signaled skepticism on plaintiff's class-certification motion and recognized the plaintiffs' radical change in their theory of the case," said NCAA general counsel Donald Remy. "This is a step in the right direction toward allowing the NCAA to further demonstrate why this case is wrong on the law and that plaintiffs have failed to demonstrate that this case satisfies the criteria for class litigation."

In her ruling, Wilken wrote that the NCAA’s claim “is not reason to preclude” the plaintiffs from moving for class certification. However, Wilken said: “These contentions are more properly considered as arguments supporting denial of the motion…on its merits.”

The lawsuit, which also names video game giant Electronic Arts (EA) as a defendant, was first unveiled in 2009 and has since been joined by big-name college athletes such as Bill Russell and Oscar Robertson.

The judge set a tentative date for a 15-day jury trial for June 2014.

Read more: http://www.foxbusiness.com/industries/2013/01/30/judge-ncaa-athletes-in-lawsuit-can-go-after-live-tv-cash/#ixzz2JUzQvSxn