Showing posts with label Twilight. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Twilight. Show all posts

Thursday, March 27, 2014

Surprising Entertainment #Lawsuits for the Week

Newsflash from your Hollywood Attorney:








Summit Entertainment has scored a round in an ongoing trademark dispute with Bath & Body Works over a line of "Twilight" fragrances.

The lawsuit has been ongoing for three years now, and BBW sought declaratory relief to establish its rights to use "Twilight Woods" and "Twilight Crush" and that it would not infringe or tarnish the marks of the producer of the blockbuster 2008 film.
On March 21, U.S. District Judge George Daniels denied a motion for summary judgment filed by BBW.
In his opinion, the New York federal judge writes that Summit has presented significant evidence that its marks are strong, and that viewing the evidence in Summit's favor, a reasonable jury could conclude similarity in trade dress and consumer confusion as to the source of the cosmetics. The judge also says that a jury could conclude that BBW intended to associate itself with Twilight.
Notwithstanding a potential settlement, the case appears headed to trial.  Read Opinion here.... http://www.scribd.com/doc/214118527/Twilight-Trademark-Opinion

Earlier this month, photographer Brian Masck kept his lawsuit alive against Sports Illustrated for allegedly infringing his iconic 1991 photo of former University of Michigan football superstar Desmond Howard doing a "Heisman" pose during a game. Now comes the follow-up lawsuit. On Monday, he filed a new copyright infringement lawsuit against ESPN. The complaint, long on backstory, says "ESPN The Magazine did everything SI did, but the photo appeared only once, in the last print appearance of the photograph, in the issue dated October 3, 2012."  Ruling..... http://www.scribd.com/doc/214661773/Heisman

50 Cent has gotten a partial victory in a lawsuit brought against a DJ who ran hip-hop website WorldStarHipHop.com. The main controversy in the lawsuit had to do with the website's masthead featuring an image of the rapper. In a ruling on Monday, a federal judge granted the hip-hop star summary judgment on copyright and right of publicity claims. In doing so, the judge rejected affirmative defenses including fair use. According to the ruling, "Defendants provide no authority to support the fair use of a celebrity’s image or likeness. This is not surprising, as a celebrity’s image, standing alone, only evokes that celebrity’s persona. Jackson’s image does not, by itself, describe anything about Defendants’ website." Read Heree.....  http://www.scribd.com/doc/214626446/50-Cent-v-World-Star-Hip-Hop-Opinion

Much has been made of an Illinois federal judge's decision at the end of last year that pretty much put most of what we know about the Sherlock Holmes character in the public domain. The case is now on appeal, and the estate of Arthur Conan Doyle figures to make some interesting arguments. Meanwhile, the estate has signaled that it intends to protect its trademarks going forward. Case in point: Last week, the estate opposed an attempt by Rocket Pictures to register "Sherlock Gnomes." Rocket intends Sherlock Gnomes to be the follow-up to its 2011 computer animated feature Gnomeo & Juliet. The Conan Doyle estate says it will dilute their own hold on Sherlock Holmes. Here's the papers filed with the Trademark Office.....   http://www.scribd.com/doc/214666850/Sherlock-Gnomes

Finally today comes a ruling from a Texas judge. In the lawsuit, the plaintiff claimed that the 1989 film Tango & Cash, starring Sylvester Stallone and Kurt Russell, defamed him because Russell's character appeared in the movie "dressed as a woman with lipstick, a woman's miniskirt, and woman's high heel shoes." The plaintiff says his teenage friends teased him because he shares the same first name ("Gabriel") as Russell's character. Of course, the claim goes nowhere. The judge fails to find any statement "of and concerning the plaintiff," and the claim was also barred by the statute of limitations.   Read Here..... http://www.scribd.com/doc/214668019/Tango-Cash


Stay Safe Out There - If You Need Help just Give Me a Call!

To schedule a free consultation and learn how we can help you, contact Beverly Hills DUI Attorney Jonathan Franklin today.

http://lawofficesofjonathanfranklin.blogspot.com/


Law Offices of Jonathan Franklin
Open Evenings and Weekends this Summer
Call Us Now (310) 273-9600   
 http://www.jonathanfranklinlaw.com


Friday, May 31, 2013

$500 Million Lawsuit for 'Twilight' Parody Company that Sues Lionsgate


The plaintiff wasn't able to find a distributor for "Twiharder" but it has a lawyer with a pretty outrageous idea.

The award for legal chutzpah this year goes to a New York attorney named James H. Freeman, who has crafted a 219-page lawsuit that accuses Lionsgate Entertainment and its subsidiary Summit Entertainment of becoming "a dominant market force in the movie industry during the last five years" on the strength of its Twilight franchise.

There's always been some tension between intellectual property law and antitrust law. IP entitles an owner to a legal monopoly while the latter aims to take apart such market control. In this whopping lawsuit -- which Bloomberg reports has actually been filed --  Lionsgate and Summit are charged with making "anticompetitive conduct" on their lucrative rights on Twilight.

Specifically, the plaintiff is Behind the Lines Productions, which says it made a feature-length film entitled Twiharder that "portrayed hyper-exaggerated caricatures from The Twilight Saga movies and lampooned expressive elements embodied in Defendants’ pre-existing works through imitative reference."

The company says several major distributors expressed interest in Twiharder, and its movie passed scrutiny by lawyers, insurers and fair use experts. Then, the defendant film companies allegedly heard about it.

"On June 27, 2012, Plaintiff became just one more victim in a long line of independent auteurs to receive a sham 'cease-and-desist' C&D Notice from Defendants," says the lawsuit. "Within days of disclosing the communication to its contractual offers, the WMPI distributors and E&O insurers unceremoniously revoked their offers to deal with Plaintiff."

Not stopping there, the lawsuit then provides  an overview of legal protections in the movie industry, the history of "movie franchises," details about the "tentpole" franchise era (with pictures of an actual tentpole construction), discussion of Twihards, critical reaction to the blockbuster films (e.g., "The Twilight Saga has also been heavily criticized by civil rights activists and academic scholars for perpetuating one-dimensional stereotypes about Native American heritage") and so forth.

Summit has long been known as aggressively protective of its intellectual property on Twilight and has endured some digerati condemnation because of this. The studio said it had no comment about the lawsuit.

See Full Complaint and Read More.... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/twilight-parody-company-sues-lionsgate-560784