Showing posts with label Warner Bros.. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Warner Bros.. Show all posts

Friday, July 5, 2013

A White House Movie "The Butler" Lawsuit, Raises Antitrust Warning with Threatening Letters


The battle over whether Harvey Weinstein can call Lee Daniels' upcoming White House movie The Butler escalated Wednesday as the Weinstein Company's superstar attorney David Boies fired off letters to Warner Bros and the MPAA threatening litigation.

In an arbitration, the MPAA's Title Registry Bureau ruled Tuesday that TWC could not use the title, because it's also the name of a preexisting 1916 short film that now resides in the Warner Bros. library.

As a signatory to the MPAA's Title Registration Bureau, Weinstein is bound by the arbitrator's ruling. The movie mogul might not like the fact that an arbitrator gave Warners the rights to The Butler, but judges are loath to do anything but confirm arbitration awards.

With the success of an appeal looking unlikely, and with TWC facing $25,000 worth of daily fines if it continues to advertise the film as The Butler, Boies is now speaking about a lawsuit. Possible claims could include extortion, misrepresentation and antitrust violations.

The letter to Warner Bros' general counsel hints at some of the discussions that preceded the title dispute.

"I am informed that Warner Bros. represented to, and agreed with, TWC that TWC would be permitted without objection by Warner Bros. to use the title “The Butler” in return for certain contributions that TWC agreed to make," writes Boies.

In his letter, Boies continues, "I am further informed that after TWC had relied on these representations and agreement, Warner Bros. repudiated those representations and agreement and sought, in concert with the MPAA, to prevent TWC from using its title."

Asked whether in order to resolve the matter quickly, TWC would consider renaming the film, which stars Forest Whitaker and is based on the true story of Eugene Allen, who spent 34 years working at the White House, Glasser said, "I have Lee Daniels' The Butler registered. I have The White House Butler registered. But what is so insane is that we've been told we can not use any version of the worlds 'the butler.' That part blows our minds."

Boies' second letter to the MPAA is even more direct about the potential antitrust claims.

"To the extent that the MPAA in concert with its members seeks to 'permanently protect' titles where there is no plausible claim of possible confusion, and no claim of actual damages, such an attempt would be a naked restraint on trade in violation of the anti-trust laws," writes Boies.

Read More.... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/butler-battle-escalates-weinstein-hints-579841

Law Offices of Jonathan Franklin
Open Evenings and Weekends this Summer
Call Us Now (310) 273-9600   
 http://www.jonathanfranklinlaw.com


Tuesday, May 21, 2013

"Smallville" - Warmer Bros Lawsuit Ended by Settling with Writers


Miles Millar and Alfred Gough had claimed millions of dollars in damages over the way WBTV handled financials on the long-running Superman series.

Although the paperwork hasn't been fully signed by all the parties, an agreement in principle has been reached to end the lawsuit that contended that Warners had robbed the show's profit participants with sweetheart license-fee deals that the studio made with its sister TV networks.

The lawsuit was one of the big ones that tested vertical integration in the entertainment industry. Filed in 2010, the lawsuit contended they were deprived of significant profits when WBTV allegedly undersold the series to affiliates the WB Network and then The CW instead of licensing the series to outside companies.

Originally, the lawsuit also included Tollin/Robbins Productions, but that portion of the lawsuit was similarly settled this past January.

The latest deal comes on the verge of a trial that was to be held in June. The plaintiffs were seeking more than $100 million in damages. Terms of the settlement aren't known.

Read More... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/warner-bros-wraps-smallville-lawsuit-525702



Friday, April 26, 2013

Warner Bros. Beat a 'Promise' to an Injured Paralyzed Chinese Gymnast Sang Lan


Sang Lan was paralyzed while preparing for the 1998 Goodwill Games. Fifteen years later, Time Warner is on the verge of defeating a lawsuit over the incident.

When a big media company puts on an international event and something goes wrong, it can be a tightrope managing the potential public relations fallout.

Sang Lan was a former world-class gymnast from China who was going to be competing in the 1998 Goodwill Games, a quadrennial competition conceived by media mogul Ted Turner and later sold to Time Warner.

As the gymnast was warming up for a vault event that year, she fell and fractured two vertebrae and her spinal cord, rendering her permanently paralyzed from the mid-chest down.

After the horrible accident, Goodwill Games President Michael Plant pledged that her medical needs would be taken care of by insurance. "I can't speak to the long-term, but it is our commitment to do what we can," he said. "Ted Turner and (then Time Warner CEO) Gerald Levin are both concerned."

Harvey Schiller, then president of Turner Sports, also made pledged to do "everything within our power to assure that her future is secure."

In a lawsuit brought in 2011, Sang alleged that didn't happen. But a magistrate judge is now recommending that Time Warner be given a soft landing.

Read Full Complaint...  http://www.scribd.com/doc/138009867/Sang

Sang said that the Chinese gymnastics team selected Kao-Sung Liu and his wife, Gina Hiu-Hung Liu to be her "guardians" to handle dealing with Time Warner. Sang says she was informed that if a negligence lawsuit was brought against the media company, "any hope of getting assistance from Time Warner would be extinguished."

Sang didn't bring a lawsuit back then. She says she could have. Among other claims, she said that experts of the sport agreed about "Time Warner's lack of organization or supervision," and the organizers allowed too many people to be in close proximity to the vault horse when athletes were performing dangerous routines. She also accused Time Warner reps of seizing tape of her injury from a man who was making a film and that they were "clearly concerned."

As the media focused on what happened immediately after the injury, and as Sang got enormous attention and hospital visitors including Celine Dion, Christopher Reeve, Leonardo DiCaprio, The Goodwill for Sang Lan Fund was set up. Time Warner contributed to it. According to Sang, "Whenever there was a question about Time Warner's responsibility, Time Warner carefully diverted the attention away from the potential liability it may have toward Sang Lan, by emphasizing the need to focus on medical issues."

The feud between Sang and the Lius continued for many years. By 2011, Sang was accusing her guardians of failing to return items donated by well-wishers and continuing to use her name and portrait in advertisements without her consent. In turn, the Lius purportedly made comments that she was lazy, couldn't urinate on her own, and planned to seek asylum in the United States.

A lawsuit brought by Sang against Time Warner for breach of contract, promissory estoppel and undertaking and reliance reached magistrate judge James Francis.

On April 19, Judge Francis issued a 66-page report that recommends that Time Warner's motion to dismiss be granted.

Regarding Sang's claim that that public comments by Time Warner executives represented an enforceable contract to secure her financial future, the judge says that the statements identified by Sang aren't specific enough. With no details about the form, frequency and amount of payment, it is deemed to be "too vague to spell out a meaningful promise."

Sang's lawyers also attempted to win on another legal theory: Time Warner had assumed a duty to provide her financial support and partially performed this duty over her care. She relied on the assumption of duty and was damaged by that reliance when she refrained from asserting her rights in a legal action against Time Warner.

Judge Francis spells out what's wrong with the theory. If Time Warner cut off support for her in 1999, as she alleges, "nothing Time Warner did prevented Ms. Sang from engaging in any course of action that was available to her prior to Time Warner's intervention. Indeed, at that point, she would even have been able to file a timely legal action against Time Warner for her injuries at the Games."

Read More... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/how-time-warner-beat-a-446597


Monday, March 4, 2013

'Superman' Heirs Still Hope to Grab Back Rights


Warner Bros. believes that the legal war can be ended before the release of "Man of Steel," but the attorney for the Jerry Siegel estate has new arguments in the long-running case.

Superman was created in the late 1930s by Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster. For three-quarters of a century since, the two have been in and out of court to gain greater financial participation. The duo and their heirs have made deals with studios along the way, and most recently, the Siegel and Shuster estates were hoping to exploit a provision of the Copyright Act that allows a copyright grant to be terminated.

In January, they were dealt a blow when Warner Bros. scored a huge win in a lawsuit that's lasted nearly a decade. Unfortunately for the Siegels and their attorney Marc Toberoff, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal ruled that in 2001, the Siegel family came to an agreement with Warners' subsidiary D.C. Comics to settle the termination fight.

Now the case is back at a lower federal court in California.

Warners smells blood and believes that a conclusion is just around the corner -- which would represent great timing because its big-budget Superman reboot Man of Steel, directed by Zack Snyder and produced by Christopher Nolan, will be released this summer.

"After over eight years of litigation, the Siegel Superman and Superboy Cases can and should now come to an end," the studio argued in legal papers filed last week.

If a contract was created, the heirs of the Superman co-creator want to argue, the Warners subsidiary didn't perform under the contract.

"DC failed to perform or to even tender performance by March 31, 2002, the date agreed upon," writes Toberoff. He continues, "DC anticipatorily breached by instead demanding unacceptable new and revised terms as a condition to its performance; accordingly, the Siegels rescinded the agreement, and DC abandoned the agreement."

Finally, Toberoff is looking to reintroduce his long-held belief (fought in various lawsuits over the years) that the Copyright Act prevents the anticipatory transfer of terminated rights through contracts. He's prevailed once before on that argument in a case involving rights to Lassie. There have been other decisions that have gone the other way -- including, most recently, against the estate of Superman's other co-creator Joe Shuster.

Toberoff's greatest challenge, though, might be judicial fatigue after eight years of a case that's been up and down and up and down the court system. He could soon find himself in a similar position as the various lawyers for Stan Lee Media Inc. who have been frustrated with judges refusing to pay much respect to countless arguments for why Spider-Man and other superhero characters were wrongfully ripped away.

Read More... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/superman-lawsuit-heirs-still-hope-425728