Showing posts with label Class action suit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Class action suit. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 30, 2013

Artist Privacy at Stake in Digital Royalties Dispute - Universal Music


A proposed class action lawsuit was launched against Universal Music Group over digital income. The litigation from Rob Zombie and Rick James on behalf of themselves and others under the UMG umbrella seeks substantial damages from the record label's decision to treat income from downloads off of venues like Apple's iTunes as "sales" instead of "licenses."

The lawyers representing the plaintiffs want UMG to turn over download revenue and volume data tied to particular artists so they are able to come up with a calculation of damages and order the information in an effort to gain class certification.

But UMG is telling a judge that's not reasonable, and if it happens, the privacy of artists will suffer.

The current litigation, in many ways, is a follow-up from a path-breaking 2010 ruling by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals over a dispute pitting Eminem's production team of Mark and Jeff Bass against Eminem's record label, Aftermath (a subsidiary of UMG). At the 9th Circuit, the judges ruled that a lower court had erred by not deeming the label's agreements with third-parties download providers as licenses instead of sales.

The attorneys for other UMG artists want to repeat the success, which would entitle these artists to collect about 50 percent of collected digital revenue instead of about 15 percent.

But this case is somewhat more complicated given the potential number of artists who have contracts with UMG. Not every artist has precisely the same contract. Not all artists enjoy the same level of success. Commonality is one of the factors that a judge will consider when deciding whether or not to certify a class action.

The plaintiffs' lawyers think that having access to data will help them sort through the issues in preparation for certification. And they're not willing to settle for data that leans on anonymity such as "Artist #437 had 1000 downloads and $785 in download revenue in 2005."

The plaintiffs are willing to designate the information potentially handed over as "Attorneys' Eyes Only," but UMG is objecting with a noteworthy argument on "third-party privacy interests."

UMG says that "the issue' here is that the plaintiffs' attorneys -- "all 50 or so of them" -- do work in the music industry. UMG lawyers states in a court filing on Friday, "Under plaintiffs' proposal, plaintiffs’ attorneys and music-industry professionals could review the private financial information of thousands of recording artists with whom they may have adverse relationships, and who have not indicated any desire to be part of any class or to be represented by these attorneys or professionals."

In the case involving Eminem music referenced above, UMG asserts that "when plaintiffs earlier sought private download data for just a single artist, Eminem... he strenuously objected, and was prepared to intervene until Plaintiffs agreed not to seek such data at all."

UMG also believes that the "true, disguised purpose in seeking the artist names is to help evaluate their case for settlement purposes."

Read More... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/universal-music-says-artist-privacy-449049


Friday, April 19, 2013

Lawsuit Over Digital Royalties - Judge won't dismiss class action Claims


A judge won't dismiss class action claims over a record label's accounting.

Like many musicians, Martha Davis has been looking at her royalty statements and wondering whether she should be getting more income when consumers buy music off of digital outlets.

Davis was the lead singer of the 1980's Los Angeles-based New Wave band, The Motels, who hit it big with the songs, "Only the Lonely" and "Suddenly Last Summer." She's among a throng of recording artists who have filed lawsuits against major record labels for not turning over enough royalties on digital music. She's the lead member of a nationwide class action against EMI Group and Capitol Records and alleges that if the defendants counted digital music as "licenses" rather than "sales" -- because there's no physical manufacturing happening on iTunes -- she's be seeing a much heftier royalty rate, per her contract.

The question for a judge in her case is whether Davis waited too long to bring her claims. Should she have filed a complaint, say, when Apple introduced iTunes 12 years ago and record labels began accounting for income there as "sales"?

On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers rejected Capitol's arguments that her claims were barred by statute of limitations.

Judge Rogers gives two big reasons in her ruling (  read in full here... http://www.scribd.com/doc/136910396/Motels   ) why her claims aren't time-barred.

First, although Capitol believed that Davis was contractually required to give written notice of an objection upon receiving a royalty statement, the judge says that the allegations arguably support a basis for tolling, meaning that the time in which she needs to object is paused. The judge says that it's a question of fact, which is another way of saying that it won't be resolved until later after the parties engage in fact-finding.

Second, the judge says that Davis can make the case that she was prevented from learning about the alleged errors by the record company's misrepresentations or concealment.

"Here, Davis alleges that Capitol knowingly underpaid her and other class members by reporting digital download licenses as sales of physical record sales, and concealed the fact that Capitol improperly accounted for sales," the judge writes.

Judge Rogers also declines to dismiss a claim for declaratory relief over Capitol's argument that it is duplicative of her claim for breach of contract. The judge also refuses to reject claims that Capitol breached a covenant of good faith and fair dealing and violated California's Unfair Competition Law.

"Davis's allegations regarding the circumstances of the fraud here are sufficiently particular," writes the judge. "The facts as to who made the decisions regarding the alleged misleading royalty statements are facts peculiarly within the control of Capitol. Davis's general allegation of Capitol's knowledge is permissible."

If Capitol can take any solace from the ruling, it's that the judge has denied the possibility of punitive damages.

Still, Capitol and EMI are facing big claims. This lawsuit brought by seven lawyers at four different law firms aims to represent others in the relevant class. According to an amended complaint, EMI's roster of artists include Coldplay, Beatie Boys, Gorillaz and Norah Jones. In general, the royalty rate for a "sale" is about 15 percent whereas for a "license," it's about 50 percent.

A side-note: Capitol Records recently experienced a big legal win against ReDigi, an upstart service which aimed to take advantage of the First Sale doctrine of copyright law to allow its users to resell "used" digital music.

In Davis' lawsuit, the lawyers quoted Capitol's ReDigi complaint in an attempt to show that record label was being somewhat two-faced by arguing in a different context that digital audio files were licensed (which would mean that they weren't subject to the First Sale doctrine). In the ReDigi complaint, the record companies used the phrase "distributes and licenses," which then got changed (among other language modifications) by Davis' lawyers as "redistributes and licenses."

Capitol wanted the judge to strike the passage from Davis' complaint.

Read More... http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/thr-esq/motels-singer-advances-lawsuit-digital-442941


Monday, March 25, 2013

NYC's Met Museum duping on fees $25.00 a ticket, Not Really!


6 million visitors a year, and most pay $25.00 when they don't have to. At the heart of a class-action lawsuit this month accusing the Met of scheming to defraud the public into believing the fees are required.

Before visitors to the Metropolitan Museum of Art can stroll past the Picassos, Renoirs, Rembrandts and other priceless works, they must first deal with the ticket line, the posted $25 adult admission and the meaning of the word in
                                    smaller type just beneath it: "recommended."

Many people, especially foreign tourists, don't see it, don't understand it or don't question it. If they ask, they are told the fee is merely a suggested donation: You can pay what you wish, but you must pay something.

Confusion over what's required to enter one of the world's great museums, which draws more than 6 million visitors a year, is at the heart of a class-action lawsuit this month accusing the Met of scheming to defraud the public into believing the fees are required.

The suit seeks compensation for museum members and visitors who paid by credit card over the past few years, though some who choose to pay less than the full price pull out a $10 or $5 bill. Some fork over a buck or loose change. Those who balk at paying anything at all are told they won't be allowed in unless they pay something, even a penny.

"I just asked for one adult general admissions and he just said, '$25,'" says Richard Johns, a high school math teacher from Little Rock, Ark., who paid the full price at the museum this past week. "It should be made clear that it is a donation you are required to make. Especially for foreign tourists who don't understand. Most people don't know it."

Met spokesman Harold Holzer denied any deception and said a policy of requiring visitors to pay at least something has been in place for more than four decades. "We are confident that the courts will see through this insupportable nuisance lawsuit," he said.

"The museum was designed to be open to everyone, without regard to their financial circumstances," said Arnold Weiss, one of two attorneys who filed the lawsuit on behalf of three museum-goers, a New Yorker and two tourists from the Czech Republic. "But instead, the museum has been converted into an elite tourist attraction."

Among the allegations are that third-party websites do not mention the recommended fee, and that the museum sells memberships that carry the benefit of free admission, even though the public is already entitled to free admission.

Lined up to testify is a former museum supervisor who oversaw and trained the Met's admissions cashiers from 2007 to 2011, said Michael Hiller, the other attorney representing the plaintiffs.

The Met's Holzer said the basis for the lawsuit — that admission is intended to be free — is wrong because the state law the plaintiffs cited has been superseded many times and the city approved pay-what-you-wish admissions in 1970.

As to the wording change on the sign, he said the museum "actually thought at the time, and still thinks, that 'recommended' is softer than 'suggested,' so the former employee is quite wrong here."

New York City's Department of Cultural Affairs agreed to the museum's request in 1970 for a general admission as long as the amount was left up to individuals and that the signage reflected that. Similar arrangements are in place for other cultural institutions that operate on city-owned land and property and receive support from the city, such as the American Museum of Natural History and the Brooklyn Museum. It's also a model that's been replicated in other cities.

The Metropolitan Museum is one of the world's richest cultural institutions, with a $2.58 billion investment portfolio, and isn't reliant on admissions fees to pay the majority of its bills. Sixteen percent of its $239 million budget in fiscal 2012 came from admissions. That same year, the city paid 11 percent of its operating budget.

                          As a nonprofit organization, the museum pays no income taxes.

Holzer also noted that in the past fiscal year, 41 percent of visitors to the Met paid the full recommended admission price — $25 for adults, $17 for seniors and $12 for students.

A random sampling of visitors leaving the museum found that there was a general awareness that "recommended" implied you could pay less than the posted price.

But Dan Larson and his son Jake, visiting the museum last week from Duluth, Minn., were unaware there was any room to negotiate the admission price. They paid the full $25 each for adult tickets, with a credit card.

"My understanding was you pay the recommended price," said Larson, 50. "That's clearly not displayed."

Alexander Kulessa, a 23-year-old university student from Germany, said friends who had previously visited New York tipped him off about the admission fee.

"They said, 'Don't pay $25,'" said Kulessa. "They said it will be written everywhere to pay $25 but you don't have to pay that. You don't even have to pay the student price."

Read More... http://news.yahoo.com/nycs-met-museum-accused-duping-fees-175540738.html

                                                            What did you pay?


Friday, February 1, 2013

Subway 'Footlong' Controversy Leads Jersey Boys To Sue Chain


Two New Jersey men sued Subway this week, claiming the world’s biggest fast-food chain has been shorting them by selling “footlong” sandwiches that measure less than 12 inches.

The suit, filed Tuesday in Superior Court in Mount Holly, N.J., might be the first legal filing aimed at the Milford, Conn.-based company since a Subway customer in Australia posted a photo of a “footlong” sub next to a ruler on the company’s Facebook page to allege that the sandwich was not as long as advertised.

Stephen DeNittis, the lawyer for the plaintiffs in the New Jersey suit, said he’s seeking class-action status and is also preparing to file a similar suit in Pennsylvania state court in Philadelphia.

He said he has had sandwiches from 17 shops measured, and every one came up short.  The lawsuit claims it is a “deceptive practice for Subway to advertise its large sandwich as a ‘footlong.’”

The lawsuit seeks compensatory damages and a change in Subway’s practices. The company should either make sure its sandwiches measure a full foot or stop advertising them as such, according to the suit.

“‘SUBWAY FOOTLONG’ is a registered trademark as a descriptive name for the sub sold in Subway Restaurants and not intended to be a measurement of length,” read a comment posted to Subway Australia’s Facebook page Jan. 16.

Prior to that statement, the company had told ABCNews.com that the size discrepancy was caused by the fact that the bread was baked fresh in each of the company’s 38,000 restaurants around the world.

“We are committed to providing a consistent product delivering the same amount of bread to the customer with every order,” the statement read. “The length however may vary slightly when not baked to our exact specifications. We are reinforcing our policies and procedures in an effort to ensure our offerings are always consistent no matter which Subway restaurant you visit.”

In response to the lawsuit, the head baker for Subway reiterated their commitment to 12 inches with each “footlong” sub.

“If proper procedures are followed, they will all measure 12 inches,” Mark Christiano told ABC News.

Read More... http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/business/2013/01/subway-sued-over-footlongs-that-came-up-short/